Cigar Review: Emilio AF1

by Matthias Clock

35 Flares 35 Flares ×

Emilio AF1

After more than 6 months of seeing Emilio Cigars pop up on my Facebook and Twitter feeds, I caved and decided I’d give the AF1 and AF2 a try. This is the first of two reviews. As far as pairings go, I originally decided to just have some water on hand. The AF1 surprised me so much that I ended up going inside to make a fresh pot of coffee – at 8pm. Disclaimer: these cigars were provided free of charge by Gary Griffith, head of Emilio.

Blend Specifics:
Wrapper: San Andreas Maduro
Binder: Nicaraguan
Filler: Nicaraguan

Appearance & Construction

Perhaps the most notable aspect of most cigars is the band. Not so with this cigar. The band is humble, with black and gold letters. What is noticeable, however, is the dark wrapper. The cigar is springy to the touch, a bit more than average. Smell on the foot is predominantly hay, nuts, cherry, and cocoa. There was also a good bit of plume.

Doodling with smoke

Taste & Smoking Characteristics

The first thing I notice when I put this cigar in my mouth is the immediate tingling on my lips. The smoke kicks off with a spicy punch, but remains cool. I’m actually really appreciative of the looser draw at this point as I’m really bringing in a lot of flavor on each puff. After about a minute, the cocoa notes become pretty obvious, though on second glance what I really taste is nice, smooth, dark chocolate. Very pleasant.
About an inch in, the spice has really backed down, letting the dark chocolate take center stage and I am really enjoying this stick. I went inside to make myself a pot of coffee, figuring it would pair well with this stick. And boy was I right.

About halfway through this cigar, I notice the spice picking up again. A welcome transition even though I was enjoying that smooth cocoa so much. Near the end, the dark chocolate again takes center stage. Absolutely fantastic.


I loved this cigar, but I should point out that that is primarily because this cigar showcased one of my favorite flavor-profiles: smooth espresso and dark chocolate. If you’re into that profile, then you just can’t go wrong with this cigar. If you enjoy cigars with a brighter profile, this might not be the cigar for you. However, if you’re in the mood to branch out into a different profile, this IS the cigar for you.

Final grade: A-

Matthias Clock

Matthias Clock

Matthias founded Fine Tobacco NYC in 2010. Originally from Portland, Oregon, he enjoys spending his spare time discussing politics, playing the guitar and piano, teaching Argentine tango, and organizing New York's cigar events. Matthias discovered and fell in love with cigars in 2007.

More Posts

Follow Me:
TwitterFacebookGoogle Plus

35 Flares Twitter 24 Facebook 11 Reddit 0 Email -- Google+ 0 35 Flares ×

Don't miss our cigar events! Free updates by email.

* indicates required

View previous campaigns.

  • Steve Wetzel

    I enjoyed this cigar very much. It is definitely a favorite of mine. I highly recommend it.

    • Matthias

      Thanks for the comment Steve. This really is a fantastic cigar. Had another one the other night and was just as impressed as the first time. – Matthias

Previous post:

Next post:

stats for wordpress