Cigar Reviews List

Below is a comprehensive list of cigar reviews completed since the end of 2017. We have a large number of reviews from 2010 – 2017 that we’ve left out of this list because those cigars were reviewed under our old letter-grading review system.

Click here to learn more about our current scoring system.

NameDateScore
601 La Bomba Warhead VI10/5/202086
Aganorsa Leaf Signature Selection Robusto11/22/201884
Aging Room Pelo De Oro2/19/201891
Aging Room Pura Cepa Mezzo9/19/201891
Aging Room Rare Collection12/31/202190
Aladino Cameroon Lonsdale11/4/202090
Alec Bradley Black Market Filthy Hooligan 202012/9/202088
Alec Bradley Medalist12/9/201988
Alec Bradley Prensado Lost Art12/21/201793
All Out King’s Give Me Your Lunch Money4/15/201983
Archetype Curses12/6/202084
Archetype Initiation Corona3/4/201882
Artesano Del Tobacco Viva La Vida3/25/201993
Artesano Del Tobacco Viva La Vida Club 5001/1/202193
Arturo Fuente Anejo Reserva No. 551/9/201889
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Double Robusto1/17/201890
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Personal Reserve7/26/201889
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature Maduro6/2/201992
AVO 22 (2018)7/2/201888
AVO 30 Years3/24/201884
AVO 30 Years Maduro Robusto5/16/201890
AVO Classic Maduro (2020)10/30/202084
Avo Improvisation LE 20208/3/202091
AVO Improvisation Series 201912/4/201987
AVO Improvisation Series LE 202111/25/202189
AVO LE0510/29/201891
AVO Regional East Edition10/4/201978
AVO Regional Edition North12/8/202091
AVO Regional Edition South12/10/202091
AVO Unexpected Moment10/7/201984
AVO Unexpected Passion10/16/201991
AVO Unexpected Tradition9/16/201992
Bandolero Seleccion Especial “Soberbios S”6/26/201988
Black Works Studios S&R9/24/201886
Blind Man’s Bluff Toro11/19/201888
Byron Reserva 5 Anos Habaneros1/4/202191
Caldwell Hit & Run Almost Robusto9/17/201885
Caldwell Lost & Found Plume1/2/202188
Caldwell The T Robusto11/21/201882
Camacho Coyolar6/25/201886
Camacho Liberty Series 202111/6/202191
Caminos El Retiro Fifth Anniversary12/23/202188
Campesino Reserva Del Padre12/31/201887
CAO Bones Blind Hughie12/1/202086
CAO Nicaragua8/7/201890
Carolina Blue Maduro Gran Robusto3/19/201886
Casa By Caldwell CdM Exclusive4/29/201990
Casa Cuba Doble Cinco2/18/201991
Casa Cuevas Limited Edition Maduro Flaco7/2/202093
Casta Mago8/29/201885
Cavalier Genève Series Black II11/30/201982
Charter Oak Habano11/18/202092
Choshi By Luxury Cigar Club12/31/202191
Cigar Clowns “The Ronald”12/27/202189
Cohiba Royale Gran Royale9/24/202093
Cornelius & Anthony Señor Esugars Robusto7/18/201888
Crowned Heads Le Carême Hermoso No. 1 Toro11/7/201891
Crowned Heads Yellow Rose1/23/201986
Daniel Marshall 24kt Golden Torpedo12/26/202060
Daniel Marshall Black Label10/8/201889
Daniel Marshall White Label Robusto11/28/201885
Daniel Marshall White Label Robusto11/28/201885
Davidoff 702 Series Aniversario Special T8/15/201888
Davidoff Aniversario Special ‘R’10/8/202088
Davidoff Aniversario Special T4/18/201888
Davidoff BLEND Exclusive Salomones11/15/202176
Davidoff Chefs Edition 202112/23/202187
Davidoff Colorado Claro Short Perfecto3/7/201892
Davidoff Dominicana Robusto8/26/202191
Davidoff Florida Selection10/15/201886
Davidoff Grand Cru Robusto9/12/202090
Davidoff Millennium Blend Short Robusto3/28/201894
Davidoff Millennium Blend Toro4/2/201895
Davidoff Nicaragua Robusto7/1/201993
Davidoff Puro D’Oro Deliciosos5/9/201893
Davidoff Robusto Intenso Limited Edition 20209/26/202090
Davidoff Royal Robusto3/12/201890
Davidoff Signature 20009/18/202091
Davidoff Small Batch No. 712/8/201992
Davidoff Special 53 Capa Dominicana (2020)10/17/202087
Davidoff Year Of The Ox12/30/202092
Davidoff Year Of The Rooster1/31/201879
Debonaire Daybreak Toro4/30/201892
Diamond Crown Maximus Toro #47/2/202089
Dias De Gloria Double Toro11/11/201986
Diesel Delirium Limited Edition 202012/19/202086
Diesel Whiskey Row Robusto10/10/201888
Diplomatico By Mombacho Cigars11/30/202090
Don Carlos Edicion De Aniversario 20134/23/201889
Don Carlos Edicion De Aniversario 20154/8/201992
Don Pepin Garcia 15th Anniversary Limited Edition Toro5/30/201888
Don Pepin Garcia Original TAA Exclusive 20197/3/201987
Drew Estate Liga Privada No. 99/15/202091
Drew Estate Liga Privada T52 Belicoso5/14/201891
Drew Estate Nasty Fritas12/18/201891
Drew Estate Undercrown ShadyXX9/19/202091
Drew Estate: Undercrown 1011/21/202191
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Sobremesa Corona Grande4/10/201992
Emilio La Musa Robusto LE 20201/11/202180
Espinosa Reggae Robusto Grande11/12/201882
Fonseca Classic (Connecticut)3/18/201986
Fonseca Cubano Limitado Robusto3/11/201987
Fonseca Nicaragua Petite Corona2/21/201885
Fonseca Vintage Robusto (2018)2/11/201988
Foundation Cigar Co El Gueguense Maduro Toro Huaco2/15/201892
Foundation The Tabernacle Robusto4/22/201992
Four Kicks Limited Edition 20188/23/201888
Fratello Bianco I Lonsdale11/14/201889
God Of Fire Aniversario 20167/2/202060
Gran Habano Blue In Green Gran Robusto12/22/201892
Gran Habano Connecticut #16/20/201886
Gran Habano Corojo #5 Gran Reserva 2012 Corona Gorda5/8/201987
Gran Habano Corojo #5 Robusto6/4/201883
Gran Habano La Conquista La Nina6/6/201889
Gran Habano Persian King Maduro10/11/201990
Gran Habano STK Zulu Zulu White6/11/201888
Guillermo Leon Robusto12/22/201890
H. Upmann Herman’s Batch11/9/202090
Highclere Castle Robusto1/24/201888
Highclere Castle Victorian 11/27/201993
Illusione OneOff Cartuchos10/3/201885
Island Jim By Oscar #2 Torpedo1/28/201984
J. London Queen’s Guard12/27/202188
J.C. Newman The American12/31/202189
JFR Lunatic Torch Dreamland1/4/202186
Joel Sherman 75th Celebration 7/9/201893
Joya De Nicaragua Antano Connecticut11/17/202090
Joya De Nicaragua Cinco Décadas Diadema8/27/201893
Joya De Nicaragua Clásico Señorita8/20/201886
Joya De Nicaragua Cuatro Cinco1/15/201889
Joya Silver Robusto9/3/201888
L’Atelier Maduro 544/25/201886
La Aurora Preferidos Sapphire Connecticut Robusto12/24/201888
La Herencia Cubana CORE5/22/201987
La Instructora Box Pressed 11/24/201791
La Instructora Delicado Robusto12/7/201988
La Instructora Force of Nature5/28/201893
La Instructora Perfection Invicto4/24/201984
La Mission De L’Atelier 19894/16/201891
La Palina Bronze Label3/13/202090
La Unica No. 4008/4/202087
Las Calaveras EL 202011/10/202090
Liga Privada Bauhaus8/27/202188
Liga Privada T52 Petit Corona12/10/201886
Liga Privada Unico Year Of The Rat (2020)7/22/202090
Macanudo Inspirado Green Toro12/2/202088
Macanudo Inspirado Red Toro8/1/201889
Martinez Patrimonio Torpedo11/9/202186
Mbombay Corojo Oscuro5/23/201886
Micallef Experiencia La Crema Toro7/8/202091
Micallef Herencia Habano Toro10/31/202091
Micallef Leyenda Special Edition11/24/202190
Micallef Migdalia Corona Extra10/20/201992
Micallef Reserva Limitada Privada8/6/202090
Montecristo Epic Craft Cured Belicoso1/20/201888
Montecristo Epic Vintage 12 Toro11/12/202191
Montecristo Espada Oscuro9/14/201991
Montecristo Grupo De Maestros Private Batch IV10/31/201886
Montecristo Nicaragua Series Robusto1/21/201987
Montecristo No. 212/2/201797
Montecristo Open Master12/5/201890
Moore & Bode Adelante2/26/201893
Moore & Bode American Fire9/5/201892
Moore & Bode American Riot5/29/201985
Moore & Bode Candela2/10/201891
Moore & Bode Flamboyân Full Brass5/7/201882
Moore & Bode Tambaku9/11/201889
Moore And Bode “Surge”4/17/201989
My Father Fonseca Robusto10/2/202093
My Father La Promesa9/27/201991
My Father The Judge Grand Robusto12/1/201987
Nat Sherman Bench 2018 No. 13/5/201992
Nat Sherman Epoca Limited Edition 20192/8/202194
Nat Sherman Panamericana Rubstico11/5/201888
Nat Sherman Timeless TAA 202012/11/202090
Nova Limited Edition Perfecto7/22/201973
Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado5/2/201893
Onyx Bold Nicaragua Toro12/18/202085
Padron Family Reserve 46 Years Maduro2/16/202091
Padron Family Reserve 50 Years Maduro5/20/201994
Padron Family Reserve No. 85 Maduro4/9/201893
Padron No. 90 Maduro7/16/201890
Partagas Limited Reserve Decadas 20202/10/202189
Patina Maduro Oxidation11/24/202088
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Maduro11/12/202077
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Sun Grown Super Toro1/2/202190
Perez-Carrillo Encore Valientes5/6/201986
Perla Del Mar Corojo Corona Gorda8/3/202187
Pichardo Clasico Sumatra Toro12/23/202187
Plasencia Alma Del Fuego Panatela9/13/201994
Plasencia Cosecha 14612/6/201789
Powstanie Broadleaf Perfecto10/17/201878
Protocol Official Misconduct11/25/201991
Protocol Sir Robert Peel Natural12/21/201992
Quesada 197410/15/201990
Quesada 1974 Toro12/23/202185
Quesada Casa Magna Box Pressed Toro1/4/201990
Quesada Casa Magna Liga F Churchill11/4/202193
Quesada Oktoberfest 10 Year Anniversary12/26/202189
Quesada Vega Magna Toro10/1/201894
Ramon Allones By AJ Fernandez8/6/201891
Ramon Allones Superiores1/30/201965
Rock-A-Feller Dominican Blue11/1/201993
Rocky Patel Cigar Smoking World Championship Robusto11/2/202089
Rocky Patel Prohibition Broadleaf3/7/201984
Rocky Patel Quarter Century12/27/202080
Rojas Street Tacos Barbacoa12/3/202188
RoMa Craft Tobac Cromagnon Mandible7/24/201994
RoMa Craft Tobac Intemperance BA XXI Ambition6/24/201992
Romeo San Andrés By Romeo Y Julieta Toro5/21/201885
Romeo Y Julieta Eternal12/23/202188
Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua11/19/202089
Room101 Farce Lonsdale9/6/201892
Room101 The Big Payback Connecticut Hueso1/16/201990
San Lotano Dominicano AJ & Joche10/28/201991
Sans Pareil Purple Belicoso12/16/201791
Southern Draw Rose Of Sharon9/22/202089
Southern Draw Rose Of Sharon “The Thorn”1/2/201989
Tatuaje 15th Anniversary Habano Rosado Belicoso Fino11/26/201889
Tatuaje Mexican Experiment II9/30/201986
Tatuaje Monster Series 2019 “The Chuck”10/31/201987
Tatuaje Regios Reserva Broadleaf2/5/201884
Tatuaje The Bride10/25/201891
The Vince By Blackbird Cigar Co.11/30/202186
Trinidad Espiritu Series No. 2 Toro12/26/202187
Trinidad Santiago1/13/201991
Trinidad Vigía10/21/201991
VegaFina 1998 VF528/20/202176
Viaje Hamaki Omakase 20199/6/201987
Viaje TNT 202112/26/202190
Warped Chinchalle Robusto11/17/202192
Warped La Relatos12/3/201892
Warped Serie Gran Reserva 198810/11/201892
Cohiba Weller11/29/202189
Wynwood Hills Mayhem Robusto3/27/201989
Yagua Toro By J.C. Newman Cigar Co.12/3/202085
Zino Platinum Master Edition Throwback 200810/10/201982