Cigar Reviews List

Below is a comprehensive list of cigar reviews completed since the end of 2017. We have a large number of other reviews from 2010 – 2017 that we’ve left out of this list because those cigars were reviewed under our old letter-grading review system.

Click here to learn more about our current scoring system.

Cigar Name Date Score
AGANORSA LEAF SIGNATURE SELECTION ROBUSTO REVIEW November 22, 2018 84
AGING ROOM PELO DE ORO REVIEW February 19, 2018 91
AGING ROOM PURA CEPA MEZZO REVIEW September 19, 2018 91
ALEC BRADLEY PRENSADO LOST ART REVIEW December 21, 2017 93
ARCHETYPE INITIATION CORONA REVIEW March 4, 2018 82
ARTURO FUENTE ANEJO RESERVA NO. 55 REVIEW January 9, 2018 89
ARTURO FUENTE DON CARLOS DOUBLE ROBUSTO REVIEW January 17, 2018 90
ARTURO FUENTE DON CARLOS PERSONAL RESERVE REVIEW July 26, 2018 89
AVO 22 (2018) REVIEW July 2, 2018 88
AVO 30 YEARS MADURO ROBUSTO REVIEW May 16, 2018 90
AVO 30 YEARS REVIEW March 24, 2018 84
AVO LE05 REVIEW October 29, 2018 91
BLACK WORKS STUDIOS S&R REVIEW September 24, 2018 86
BLIND MAN’S BLUFF TORO REVIEW November 19, 2018 88
CALDWELL HIT & RUN ALMOST ROBUSTO REVIEW September 17, 2018 85
CALDWELL THE T ROBUSTO REVIEW November 21, 2018 82
CAMACHO COYOLAR REVIEW June 25, 2018 86
CAMPESINO RESERVA DEL PADRE REVIEW December 31, 2018 87
CAO NICARAGUA REVIEW August 7, 2018 90
CAROLINA BLUE MADURO GRAN ROBUSTO REVIEW March 19, 2018 86
CASA CUBA DOBLE CINCO REVIEW February 18, 2019 91
CASTA MAGO REVIEW August 29, 2018 85
CORNEIUS & ANTHONY SEÑOR ESUGARS ROBUSTO REVIEW July 18, 2018 88
CROWNED HEADS LE CARÊME HERMOSO NO. 1 TORO REVIEW November 7, 2018 91
CROWNED HEADS YELLOW ROSE REVIEW January 23, 2019 86
DANIEL MARSHALL BLACK LABEL REVIEW October 8, 2018 89
DANIEL MARSHALL WHITE LABEL ROBUSTO REVIEW November 28, 2018 85
DAVIDOFF 702 SERIES ANIVERSARIO SPECIAL T REVIEW August 15, 2018 88
DAVIDOFF ANIVERSARIO SPECIAL T REVIEW April 18, 2018 88
DAVIDOFF COLORADO CLARO SHORT PERFECTO REVIEW March 7, 2018 92
DAVIDOFF FLORIDA SELECTION REVIEW October 15, 2018 86
DAVIDOFF MILLENNIUM BLEND SHORT ROBUSTO REVIEW March 28, 2018 94
DAVIDOFF MILLENNIUM BLEND TORO REVIEW April 2, 2018 95
DAVIDOFF PURO D’ORO DELICIOSOS REVIEW May 9, 2018 93
DAVIDOFF ROYAL ROBUSTO REVIEW March 12, 2018 90
DAVIDOFF YEAR OF THE ROOSTER REVIEW January 31, 2018 79
DEBONAIRE DAYBREAK TORO REVIEW April 30, 2018 92
DIESEL WHISKEY ROW ROBUSTO REVIEW October 10, 2018 88
DON CARLOS EDICION DE ANIVERSARIO 2013 REVIEW April 23, 2018 89
DON PEPIN GARCIA 15TH ANNIVERSARY LIMITED EDITION TORO REVIEW May 30, 2018 88
DREW ESTATE LIGA PRIVADA T52 BELICOSO REVIEW May 14, 2018 91
DREW ESTATE NASTY FRITAS REVIEW December 18, 2018 91
ESPINOSA REGGAE ROBUSTO GRANDE REVIEW November 12, 2018 82
FONSECA CLASSIC (CONNECTICUT) REVIEW March 18, 2019 86
FONSECA CUBANO LIMITADO ROBUSTO REVIEW March 11, 2019 87
FONSECA NICARAGUA PETITE CORONA REVIEW February 21, 2018 85
FONSECA VINTAGE ROBUSTO (2018) REVIEW February 11, 2019 88
FOUR KICKS LIMITED EDITION 2018 REVIEW August 23, 2018 88
FRATELLO BIANCO I LONSDALE REVIEW November 14, 2018 89
GRAN HABANO BLUE IN GREEN GRAN ROBUSTO REVIEW December 22, 2018 92
GRAN HABANO CONNECTICUT #1 REVIEW June 20, 2018 86
GRAN HABANO COROJO #5 ROBUSTO REVIEW June 4, 2018 83
GRAN HABANO LA CONQUISTA LA NINA REVIEW June 6, 2018 89
GRAN HABANO STK ZULU ZULU WHITE REVIEW June 11, 2018 88
GUILLERMO LEON ROBUSTO REVIEW December 22, 2018 90
HIGHCLERE CASTLE ROBUSTO REVIEW January 24, 2018 88
ILLUSIONE ONEOFF CARTUCHOS REVIEW October 3, 2018 85
ISLAND JIM BY OSCAR #2 TORPEDO REVIEW January 28, 2019 84
JOEL SHERMAN 75TH CELEBRATION CIGAR REVIEW July 9, 2018 93
JOYA DE NICARAGUA CINCO DÉCADAS DIADEMA REVIEW August 27, 2018 93
JOYA DE NICARAGUA CLÁSICO SEÑORITA REVIEW August 20, 2018 86
JOYA DE NICARAGUA CUATRO CINCO REVIEW January 15, 2018 89
JOYA SILVER ROBUSTO REVIEW September 3, 2018 88
L’ATELIER MADURO 54 REVIEW April 25, 2018 86
LA AURORA PREFERIDOS SAPPHIRE CONNECTICUT ROBUSTO REVIEW December 24, 2018 88
LA INSTRUCTORA BOX PRESSED CIGAR REVIEW November 24, 2017 91
LA MISSION DE L’ATELIER 1989 REVIEW April 16, 2018 91
LIGA PRIVADA T52 PETIT CORONA REVIEW December 10, 2018 86
LIMITED EDITION LA INSTRUCTORA REVIEW May 28, 2018 93
MACANUDO INSPIRADO RED TORO REVIEW August 1, 2018 89
MBOMBAY COROJO OSCURO REVIEW May 23, 2018 86
MONTECRISTO EPIC CRAFT CURED BELICOSO REVIEW January 20, 2018 88
MONTECRISTO GRUPO DE MAESTROS PRIVATE BATCH IV REVIEW October 31, 2018 86
MONTECRISTO NICARAGUA SERIES ROBUSTO REVIEW January 21, 2019 87
MONTECRISTO (CUBA) NO. 2 REVIEW December 2, 2017 97
MONTECRISTO (CUBA) OPEN MASTER REVIEW December 5, 2018 90
MOORE & BODE ADELANTE REVIEW February 26, 2018 93
MOORE & BODE AMERICAN FIRE REVIEW September 5, 2018 92
MOORE & BODE CANDELA REVIEW February 10, 2018 91
MOORE & BODE FLAMBOYÂN FULL BRASS REVIEW May 7, 2018 82
MOORE & BODE TAMBAKU REVIEW September 11, 2018 89
NAT SHERMAN BENCH 2018 NO. 1 REVIEW March 5, 2019 92
NAT SHERMAN PANAMERICANA RUBSTICO REVIEW November 5, 2018 88
OLIVA SERIE V MELANIO FIGURADO REVIEW May 2, 2018 93
PADRON FAMILY RESERVE NO. 85 MADURO REVIEW April 9, 2018 93
PADRON NO. 90 MADURO REVIEW July 16, 2018 90
PLASENCIA COSECHA 146 REVIEW December 6, 2017 89
POWSTANIE BROADLEAF PERFECTO REVIEW October 17, 2018 78
RAMON ALLONES BY AJ FERNANDEZ REVIEW August 6, 2018 91
RAMON ALLONES (CUBA) SUPERIORES REVIEW January 30, 2019 65
ROCKY PATEL PROHIBITION BROADLEAF REVIEW March 7, 2019 84
ROMEO SAN ANDRÉS BY ROMEO Y JULIETA TORO REVIEW May 21, 2018 85
ROOM 101 FARCE LONSDALE REVIEW September 6, 2018 92
ROOM101 THE BIG PAYBACK CONNECTICUT HUESO REVIEW January 16, 2019 90
SANS PAREIL PURPLE BELICOSO REVIEW December 16, 2017 91
SOUTHERN DRAW ROSE OF SHARON “THE THORN” REVIEW January 2, 2019 89
TATUAJE 15TH ANNIVERSARY HABANO ROSADO BELICOSO FINO REVIEW November 26, 2018 89
TATUAJE REGIOS RESERVA BROADLEAF REVIEW February 5, 2018 84
TATUAJE THE BRIDE REVIEW October 25, 2018 91
TRINIDAD SANTIAGO REVIEW January 13, 2019 91
VEGA MAGNA TORO REVIEW October 1, 2018 94
VIVA LA VIDA CIGAR REVIEW March 25, 2019 93
WARPED LA RELATOS REVIEW December 3, 2018 92
WARPED SERIE GRAN RESERVA 1988 REVIEW October 11, 2018 92
WYNWOOD HILLS MAYHEM ROBUSTO REVIEW March 27, 2019 89

By using this website you agree to accept our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions