Cigars in New York City
RSS
Fine Tobacco NYC
  • Events
    • Private Events
    • Cigar 101 Classes
    • Whisky 101 Classes
  • Blog
    • Cigar Reviews
    • Whiskey Reviews
    • Top Cigars – 2017
    • Top 10 – 2018
    • Top 10 – 2019
    • Top 10 – 2020
    • Top 10 – 2021
    • Top 10 – 2022
    • Cigar Reviews List
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Our Scoring System
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy / Terms and Conditions
April 17, 2019
Cigar Reviews Moore and Bode

Moore and Bode “Surge” Review

Christian
7 0 3.6k
Share

Moore & Bode Surge Review

Moore & Bode Cigars have been around since 1990 based in Miami. Independently owned, the company has been producing cigars from around the world and is currently sourcing tobacco from locations such as Asia, India and South America. While not disclosing specific regions or farms, Moore & Bode seeks to find unique flavors and quality tobacco.

I’ve only smoked the Classic line which I enjoyed for its mild complexity. With that experience I was looking forward to a fuller flavored blend in their “Surge” cigar.

Blend Specifics

  • Cigar Reviewed: Moore & Bode Surge
  • Wrapper: Indonesian Sun Grown Colorado
  • Binder: Asia
  • Filler: Caribbean, South American, India
  • Size: 5”x 46

Moore & Bode Surge Review

Appearance & Construction

The Moore & Bode Surge sports a milk chocolate wrapper with minimal veins. Its semi firm to the touch save for a soft spot at the foot. The band is a standout orange with cream lines a top and bottom with the Moore and Bode logo on it. There’s a secondary band at the foot in the same coloring with the word “Surge” on it. The cigar is well crafted and the roll spot on.

Flavor & Smoke Characteristics

After using a straight Xikar cut, I toast the Surge and with the first few puffs comes a blast of spice that tingles all over my palate and enlivens the senses. The Surge certainly lives up to its name, greeting you with a “surge” of power upfront. On the retrohale, there’s lots of cedar along with pepper.  As the cigar progresses, sweetness and coconut begin developing on the palate. Then, the Surge turns a bit creamy, with copious amounts of smoke. Thus far the flavors of the Moore & Bode Surge are quite enjoyable.

During the second half of the Surge, I pick up some sour cherry and candy notes. Construction here isn’t flawless: the cigar develops a white, flaky ash and ends up needing a relight. A few puffs later, the sour cherry notes give way to a cinnamon and sugar note that creates a sweet sensation on the tongue. The retrohale, on the other hand, brings up some earthiness with a sweet and savory finish on the palate.

The last third requires another relight and the burn becomes uneven. The cherry flavors continue with added vegetal notes. And, what was once earthiness becomes a distinct grassy note, with a bit of harshness despite a slow burn. Graphite dominates the mouthfeel in the last inch or so, and I’m met with another swath of bitterness. At this point the profile turned and I let the cigar put itself out to conclude the smoke.

Conclusion

The Moore and Bode Surge delivers power, with spice to start, helping it live up to its moniker. The transition from spice to sweet and cinnamon was pleasant and the savory notes when they appeared were wonderful. The Surge lost it a bit on the last third with some vegetal and grassiness that were off-putting.

Overall the quality of tobaccos were there and being able to taste what nontraditional countries are producing is quite an education. I recommend picking up a few to smoke and age and see how this blend progresses. The ability to smoke a cigar and understand the flavors of tobaccos grown all over the world is an experience an aficionado should take advantage of.

Moore & Bode are showing what thinking outside the usual realm of tobacco countries can produce.

Final Rating: 89 points

April 15, 2019
Cigar Reviews Caldwell Cigars

All Out King’s Give Me Your Lunch Money Review

Matthias Clock
4 0 3.1k
Share

To me, Caldwell Cigar Co‘s brand is most easily defined by the great artwork on the bands, the eclectic naming conventions (as evidenced in this review), and with producing cigars that are rich, complex, and full bodied. Today’s review focuses on the All Out King’s “Give Me Your Lunch Money.” The cigar is produced at the Drew Estate factory in Esteli, Nicaragua, and features tobaccos from an array of countries, including Indonesia.

All Out King’s is the company’s first collaboration project, and, given Caldwell’s unorthodox brand, Drew Estate seems like a fitting partner in crime.

Blend Specifics

  • Cigar Reviewed: All Out King’s “Give Me Your Lunch Money”
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Stalk Cut and Sun Cured Habano Wrapper
  • Binder: Indonesian Sumatra
  • Filler: Jalapa Viso, Esteli Viso, Dominican C-98 Seco, and Connecticut Broadleaf Ligero
  • Size: 5 3/4″ x 46

Appearance & Construction

The All Out King’s Give Me Your Lunch Money sports one of the most visually unique wrappers I’ve seen… ever. The variation of colors is stunning, with the leaf alternating between a light reddish brown and dark brown all around the cigar. The texture is interesting as well. There’s a light oily layer, but a visual toothiness that makes the wrapper feel leathery to the touch.

After using a straight cut to cut the cigar, the draw seems to be a touch tight, about an 8/10 in terms of amount of restrictiveness. The cold draw has some granola and oats, but the aroma off of the foot is much stronger, with dry cedar, cocoa beans, and some white pepper rounding it all out.

Flavor & Smoke Characteristics

Give Me Your Lunch Money (or GMYLM for practicality’s sake) kicks off with hearty medium bodied smoke. Smoke production is good, but not quite voluminous. From a flavor standpoint, the cigar lands more toward the bitter end of the flavor spectrum, though there is a bit of sweet cocoa and a salty buttered popcorn that pops in the aroma. The base notes are bitter cedar, finely-ground black pepper and pencil lead. One thing that really catches my eye though as I smoke through the first inch is that it is mainly the back/sides of my palate that are activated by the cigar, instead of the center and tip of the tongue which is more common. As the cigar burns on, a straight white ash develops with a great burn.

Just past the first inch mark, the bitter elements of the flavor profile really ramp up, leading me to take a quick break to grab a glass of water. Body at this point is at about medium, but I find the flavor strength to be way up at full. The smoke is chock full of oak and black pepper on the palate (perhaps a bit overdone) with with contrasting aromas of popcorn, floral, and dark stone fruits in the aroma. The retrohale is similarly aggressive, with heavy pepper and charred oak making up most of the flavor.

The second third of GMYLM is mostly the same, with the body staying at medium and flavor staying near full. The smoke has a chalky texture, with predominantly bitter notes of oak, pepper, minerality, and some slight sweetness. There is a white pepper note that’s introduced, mainly activating on the tip of the tongue. Overall though, it’s more of the same, and at this point I’m finding the bitterness of the profile to be taxing on my palate.

In the final third of the All Out King’s GMYLM, the flavors finally come into a bit more balance, with oak and pepper joined by dark chocolate, savory spices, and sweet floral. The retrohale features red pepper and generic wood. Construction remains just about perfect, with a straight burn circling the cigar and the ash holding easily for more than an inch. Not a bad way to end, but too little too late.

Conclusion

While All Out King’s “Give Me Your Lunch Money” has some good qualities to speak for it, finesse is not one of them. If you’re looking for an elegant smoke, this is not it. But if you’re a full bodied cigar smoker, it’s worth a shot. For me, though, as much as I’ve loved just about everything I’ve smoked from Caldwell, this cigar would have to land on the bottom end of that list. The bitter, oaky elements of the smoke were just too aggressive, rarely letting up to allow other flavors a chance to shine.

Final Rating: 83

April 10, 2019
Cigar Reviews Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Sobremesa Corona Grande Review

Matthias Clock
4 0 3.1k
Share

Sobremesa Corona Grande

There are few boutique brands on the market today that carry the kind of reputation for craftsmanship and skill as Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust. In just a few short years, Steve Saka has turned this once-unknown brand into something of a household name among boutique cigar smokers. And, as you’ll find out in this review, for good reason.

Blend Specifics

  • Cigar Reviewed: Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Sobremesa
  • Wrapper: Ecuadorian Rosado
  • Binder: Mexican
  • Filler: Nicaraguan / Pennsylvania Broadleaf ligero
  • Size: 5.2″ x 44 Corona Grande

Sobremesa Corona Grande

Appearance & Construction

Sobremesa comes wrapped in a beautiful rosado wrapper finished with a golden band resembling a crown. The outer wrapper is smooth to the touch with a slight layer of oil and just one major vein running from the cap to about the second third.

When squeezed, the cigar has a fair amount of give, but it seems packed consistently throughout. The draw is perfect, a 7/10 in terms of restrictiveness, and the cold draw reveals notes of white pepper, spices, earth, and sweet granola.

Flavor & Smoke Characteristics

Once lit, the Sobremesa Corona Grande produces plumes of thick, mild-bodied, white smoke. The first word that comes to my mind after a few puffs is finesse. The smoke is light, incredibly smooth, but quite flavorful. And a unique flavor profile it is. Lots of almonds, light baking spices, paper, a touch of saltiness, and a slight bitterness on the palate. The retrohale mimics the palate, with an almost imperceptible strength and flavors of almonds, cinnamon, and oats. As the white ash develops past the first half inch, the burn is razor sharp.

Sobremesa Corona Grande

The flavors on the Sobremesa Corona Grande begin developing more at about an inch or more in. Strength and body are now solidly at mild, and the profile is moving away from soft bitterness on the palate and more toward sweetness, something akin to snickerdoodle cookies. Some wood sneaks its way in as well, along with some faint vegetal notes that are barely perceptible. Lastly, there’s also a bit of spice that comes in and out on the palate but is felt more consistently on the retrohale, giving a bit more dimension to the smoking experience. It’s an excellent continuation of the story, but I’m ready for a bit more strength and body to this smoke.

While the Sobremesa does indeed continue its slow climb in strength for most of the second third, it only barely makes it above medium by the beginning of the final third. That said, it retains its almost unbelievable amount of smoothness with each puff, which in and of itself is quite a feat.

As the cigar burns into the final third, the strength finally kicks in, moving up to just below medium. The palate gets a bit rougher, but adds more flavors, including charred wood, bitter dark chocolate, and a well-defined black pepper on the tip of the tongue that’s also quite evident on the retrohale. As the strength increases, there are times that a bit of harshness enters the smoke, but by and large it’s a well-integrated conclusion to the cigar.

Conclusion

To me, Sobremesa Corona Grande is the kind of cigar that’s creates such an elegant sensation on the palate that, once experienced, it’s really quite impossible to buy the whole “Cubans are best” party line that I see touted so often on platforms like Instagram. The cigar puts together a well-crafted, compelling flavor story. The only thing holding this cigar back from a higher score is its overall mildness which I wish would have ramped up a bit earlier. Of course, that’s a subjective note, but it’s my honest opinion. I’d be curious to see how other sizes perform with respect to this observation.

Either way, this is a cigar to seek out.

Final Rating; 92

April 8, 2019
Cigar Reviews Arturo Fuente

Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 Review

Matthias Clock
3 0 6.8k
Share

Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 review

Up for review today is the Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 from Aturo Fuente cigars. The Edicion de Aniversario series dates back to 2006, when the first blend in the series was introduced to celebrate the 30th anniversary of the original Don Carlos line. In 2018, I reviewed the Don Carlos Edicion Aniversario 2013 and found it to be good, albeit flawed at a price point of $30. So when I received the 2015 blend from Luxury Cigar Club, I was excited to see if the blend had improved.

Blend Specifics

  • Cigar Reviewed: Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015
  • Wrapper: Dominican Sun Grown Habano
  • Binder: Dominican Republic
  • Filler: Dominican Republic
  • Size: 5.7″ x 52 Double Robusto

Appearance & Construction

As is typical with Arturo Fuente cigars, the Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 is impeccably branded and has a celebratory quality to it. The outer wrapper has a visible oily sheen and a smooth feel to the fingers.  Taking a whiff off of the foot, I pick up rich notes of earth, hay, and garden vegetable notes. There’s also a slight cinnamon sweetness that I hope shows up in the smoke. The cold draw is malty, with some granola and spicy white pepper.

The draw is perfect.

Flavor & Smoke Characteristics

When the Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 ignites, it produces large plumes of white, medium bodied smoke. Generally, the flavor profile falls in the savory, bitter, and spicy flavor categories. On the draw, the smoke is quite smooth, with a creamy entry. On the palate the flavors that emerge are vegetation, strong cedar, Wasabi spice on the tip of the tongue, and touches of creamy coffee that coats the palate. It’s the kind of flavor profile I’ve only ever found with Arturo Fuente cigars (open to suggestions for similar cigars). The retrohale is similar, with a healthy but not overwhelming amount of Wasabi spice and dry cedar. A great start.

Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 review

About ten minutes in, the rough edges on the flavors have smoothed out and the cigar is remarkably complex, harmonious, and balanced. The spice is perfectly measured next to the sweet cream, cedar, and vegetal notes, making it a joy to smoke.

The ash holds up until the beginning of the second third, and the burn remains mostly straight when the ash finally drops. And, like clockwork, the strength of the smoke increases dramatically. Cedar takes the dominant role on the palate while the Wasabi note eases down to a secondary position, along with rich coffee bean, floral, and a creamy finish. The retrohale is smooth, but still full of white and red pepper. It’s great transition for the overall experience.

The Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 smokes this way until just about the final third, where it ramps up in strength and body even more, landing at medium to full body and full strength. On the palate are predominantly bitter notes of vegetal, cedar, Wasabi and coffee beans. Unfortunately, the cream that balanced those flavors out in the first two thirds disappears, but the smoke is still very smooth. The retrohale on the other hand has large helpings of hot spices that clear the sinuses. It’s not quite as compelling of an experience as the first two thirds, which is a bit of a let down given how spot on the rest of the experience was.

Conclusion

Even with a slightly weaker final third, the Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario 2015 is an excellent cigar and I can wholeheartedly recommend it. The flavor profile has great complexity, featuring just about everything I love about Fuente cigars: well proportioned spice, cedar, floral, and wonderful creaminess that balances it all out. The final third couldn’t quite live up to the two thirds leading up to it, but it is still an all around excellent cigar that I think justifies the high price tag.

Final Rating: 92

April 3, 2019
Guest Post, Interview

Between the Leaves: Raymond Pages Raffo of Tabacalera AJ Fernandez

Andrew Perelson
7 4 9.9k
Share

The top dog gets all of the scraps.  For that reason, there is never going to be a shortage of homages to all the gentlemen and women who make up the upper echelon of the cigar industry.  They own the Tabacaleras, they are the blenders, their name is on the band, their evenings are vibrant and adventurous full of booze and cigars. They travel the globe, they get the fame, and we share in the bounty of their incredible work.

This group gets 99% of the typical articles and series that are produced in the industry. And why not?  How would one even begin to write about the underbelly, the realness, of the industry?  You’d have to embed yourself in a tabacalera or deep within a brand’s employee roster to find that proper individual who could represent the truly interesting aspects of the cigar industry.

I believe passionately that profiling the people behind-the-scenes in the industry would be more interesting than most celebrity spots and would broaden the everyday cigar lovers knowledge of the seed to shelf process.

That’s why I have been connecting with friends in the cigar industry on Facebook and Linkedin for many years. I go about it like this: first, I connect with certain avatars that illuminate the industry as a whole, and then connect with their connections throughout the value chain (sales, operations, etc). In those years, I’ve connected with a cadre of the most amazing people in the cigar industry, from top to bottom. From owners and sales professionals to marketers, blenders, and factory workers.

These are the people I am interested in.

More than travelling the world and having a cigar every day in a new location, what interests me is what goes on in the Tabacalera.  What’s the difference between good to great? And how do the pieces fit together? It’s not so easy to figure out. There is no step by step about what goes on, and when you do finally see something on a Tabacalera, it is from the “rich” perspective of being a distinguished guest sipping on rum in the shade.

Beyond that, my connections are mostly great personalities. Sadly, these friendships overall are not deep but I would say that more than most I have really made an effort to become someone who enjoys the nuances and interests of my Facebook friends and I comment more than most about the normal aspects of people’s lives.  I like it when A.J. shows him petting his horses and riding. I like the birthday parties for mom and the pictures of the early mornings in airports with the hair all in a miff. And I like the work.  Seeing the all the different leaves laid out and sorted through.  Taking in the piles of freshly rolled cigars on tables in climate controlled rooms.  That’s the stuff that interests me.  I spend the majority of my time handling extremely technical work in the transportation industry and spending time with my family.  I have found that the salt of the industry does the same!

The subject of our first profile is Raymond Pages Raffo.  I connected with him though Abdel Yusef Fernandez, Rafael Nodal, and Nick Melillo who each have a relationship with him.

Ray is employed in a trusted role as the Head of his Operation by A.J. Fernandez.  This is quite a responsibility for a young man like Ray, but he takes it very seriously and is tireless in his role.  Rafael and Nick find him as the point person on their creative pursuit of the finest Nicaraguan tobaccos from the fields of A.J. Fernandez and the warehouse. Judging by how they talk about him, it’s clear that they respect his knowledge and that they like him as a person.  This is his job for all who come to the factory. God, and what a job it is.

Ray at work #1 (1)

Ray is 25 and lives in Esteli.  Like many in this industry, he was born in Cuba where his parents grew tobacco when he was a young boy.  You ask how at 25 he slipped into this sweet role? Well, he happens to be A.J.’s brother in law! As the Operations Leader for AJ’s factory, Tabacalera Fernandez,  he’s the fellow that AJ trusts with selection of the tobacco and the sourcing of all part and ingredients.  He is one of the top two people overall!

Ray did not start out at the top. He started working in the factory at 18, quickly showed is dedication and skill, and became integral in supervision of the manufacturing process.  In describing what he does, he tells me that Abdel does all the blends and he does everything else including searching for the tobaccos for A.J. to try prior to choosing the blend.  He puts together what he calls the “tabscos” as he call them for A.J. to try before choosing the blends.  These are basic rolls that look like Backwoods Smokes from the pharmacy.  They are comprised completely of the same leaf and it allows blenders to get the taste of a specific part more fully.

Ray is also a bad ass.  If you look at the goings on of his day to day in his life, he smokes a giant strong cigar mostly something he is proud to have worked on.  He looks scary because he owns the smoke, nothing dainty from Ray! Also, because he works hard during the day, he smokes this giant cigar without much handling, so it’s in his mouth and then he is done. He is also a family man and likes the goings on at his home in Esteli with his kids.  He often BBQs with his friends and he is always a fixture around the goings on of A.J.’s social and family life.

I asked Ray what his favorite smokes are and unsurprisingly they are the ones he has worked on with pride from the Tabacalero.  The first being the Ramon Allones by AJ Fernandez. This is a classic Cuban name and the Nicaraguan version is maybe better. According to lore, the brand was A.J.’s father’s favorite back in Cuba, so his send up was something he really worked hard on with Ray.  He also mentions in our communication how much he loves the H Upmann by A.J.  This certainly is a tough cigar to put out as Upmann has 170 years of greatness and you can’t just screw with that.  Also the Montecristo Nicaragua which has been tearing up the reviews as it was a collaboration with Rafael Nodal.  To say that A.J. and Rafael work well together is an understatement, and right behind them in their efforts is Ray.

I hope to visit Ray in Esteli and see him in action.  During which I would take part in one of his chicken BBQs!  At 25, Ray has the respect of all blenders and the trust of one of the best, Abdel Yusef.  He should be proud of his place in the process and I know that by the time he is 35 he will be doing ever more amazing things!


Note: this post is re-shared with permission by Kaplowitz Media. View the original post here.

«‹ 85 86 87 88›»

Popular Articles

  • The Best and Worst Websites to Buy Cigars OnlineThe Best (and Worst) Websites to Buy Cigars Online in 2025
    March 9, 2024
  • The Ultimate Luxury Cigar Accessories List (2023)The Ultimate Luxury Cigar Accessories List (2023)
    January 4, 2023
  • Opinion: The Best Cigars from Oliva CigarsOpinion: The Best Cigars from Oliva Cigars
    January 1, 2023
  • The Best New Cigars to Smoke in 2023The Best New Cigars to Smoke in 2023
    January 1, 2023
  • Opinion: The Best Cigars from Davidoff CigarsOpinion: The Best Cigars from Davidoff Cigars
    May 29, 2022

Recent Posts

  • tog release 2024The Tobacconist of Greenwich Unveils Rare Finds Blend 1229-42
    August 6, 2024
  • AVO CigarsAVO Cigars Launches AVO Expressions 2024 Featuring Collaboration with DJ D-Nice
    April 2, 2024
  • LUXURY CIGARLuxury Cigar Club Expands Its Presence with Rail City Cigars Partnership
    March 28, 2024
  • XIKAR-Flip-PRIntroducing the XIKAR Flip Dual Cutter at the PCA Trade Show
    March 28, 2024
  • Drew EstateDrew Estate Celebrates Lunar New Year with Liga Privada Unico Serie Bakkwa
    March 28, 2024
© Fine Tobacco NYC 2025
Powered by WordPress • Themify WordPress Themes