Cigar Reviews List

Below is a comprehensive list of cigar reviews completed since the end of 2017. We have a large number of reviews from 2010 – 2017 that we’ve left out of this list because those cigars were reviewed under our old letter-grading review system.

Click here to learn more about our current scoring system.

Name Date Score
601 La Bomba Warhead VI 10/5/2020 86
Aganorsa Leaf Signature Selection Robusto 11/22/2018 84
Aging Room Pelo De Oro 2/19/2018 91
Aging Room Pura Cepa Mezzo 9/19/2018 91
Aging Room Rare Collection 12/31/2021 90
Aladino Cameroon Lonsdale 11/4/2020 90
Alec Bradley Black Market Filthy Hooligan 2020 12/9/2020 88
Alec Bradley Medalist 12/9/2019 88
Alec Bradley Prensado Lost Art 12/21/2017 93
All Out King’s Give Me Your Lunch Money 4/15/2019 83
Archetype Curses 12/6/2020 84
Archetype Initiation Corona 3/4/2018 82
Artesano Del Tobacco Viva La Vida 3/25/2019 93
Artesano Del Tobacco Viva La Vida Club 500 1/1/2021 93
Arturo Fuente Anejo Reserva No. 55 1/9/2018 89
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Double Robusto 1/17/2018 90
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Personal Reserve 7/26/2018 89
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature Maduro 6/2/2019 92
AVO 22 (2018) 7/2/2018 88
AVO 30 Years 3/24/2018 84
AVO 30 Years Maduro Robusto 5/16/2018 90
AVO Classic Maduro (2020) 10/30/2020 84
Avo Improvisation LE 2020 8/3/2020 91
AVO Improvisation Series 2019 12/4/2019 87
AVO Improvisation Series LE 2021 11/25/2021 89
AVO LE05 10/29/2018 91
AVO Regional East Edition 10/4/2019 78
AVO Regional Edition North 12/8/2020 91
AVO Regional Edition South 12/10/2020 91
AVO Unexpected Moment 10/7/2019 84
AVO Unexpected Passion 10/16/2019 91
AVO Unexpected Tradition 9/16/2019 92
Bandolero Seleccion Especial “Soberbios S” 6/26/2019 88
Black Works Studios S&R 9/24/2018 86
Blind Man’s Bluff Toro 11/19/2018 88
Byron Reserva 5 Anos Habaneros 1/4/2021 91
Caldwell Hit & Run Almost Robusto 9/17/2018 85
Caldwell Lost & Found Plume 1/2/2021 88
Caldwell The T Robusto 11/21/2018 82
Camacho Coyolar 6/25/2018 86
Camacho Liberty Series 2021 11/6/2021 91
Caminos El Retiro Fifth Anniversary 12/23/2021 88
Campesino Reserva Del Padre 12/31/2018 87
CAO Bones Blind Hughie 12/1/2020 86
CAO Nicaragua 8/7/2018 90
Carolina Blue Maduro Gran Robusto 3/19/2018 86
Casa By Caldwell CdM Exclusive 4/29/2019 90
Casa Cuba Doble Cinco 2/18/2019 91
Casa Cuevas Limited Edition Maduro Flaco 7/2/2020 93
Casta Mago 8/29/2018 85
Cavalier Genève Series Black II 11/30/2019 82
Charter Oak Habano 11/18/2020 92
Choshi By Luxury Cigar Club 12/31/2021 91
Cigar Clowns “The Ronald” 12/27/2021 89
Cohiba Royale Gran Royale 9/24/2020 93
Cornelius & Anthony Señor Esugars Robusto 7/18/2018 88
Crowned Heads Le Carême Hermoso No. 1 Toro 11/7/2018 91
Crowned Heads Yellow Rose 1/23/2019 86
Daniel Marshall 24kt Golden Torpedo 12/26/2020 60
Daniel Marshall Black Label 10/8/2018 89
Daniel Marshall White Label Robusto 11/28/2018 85
Daniel Marshall White Label Robusto 11/28/2018 85
Davidoff 702 Series Aniversario Special T 8/15/2018 88
Davidoff Aniversario Special ‘R’ 10/8/2020 88
Davidoff Aniversario Special T 4/18/2018 88
Davidoff BLEND Exclusive Salomones 11/15/2021 76
Davidoff Chefs Edition 2021 12/23/2021 87
Davidoff Colorado Claro Short Perfecto 3/7/2018 92
Davidoff Dominicana Robusto 8/26/2021 91
Davidoff Florida Selection 10/15/2018 86
Davidoff Grand Cru Robusto 9/12/2020 90
Davidoff Millennium Blend Short Robusto 3/28/2018 94
Davidoff Millennium Blend Toro 4/2/2018 95
Davidoff Nicaragua Robusto 7/1/2019 93
Davidoff Puro D’Oro Deliciosos 5/9/2018 93
Davidoff Robusto Intenso Limited Edition 2020 9/26/2020 90
Davidoff Royal Robusto 3/12/2018 90
Davidoff Signature 2000 9/18/2020 91
Davidoff Small Batch No. 7 12/8/2019 92
Davidoff Special 53 Capa Dominicana (2020) 10/17/2020 87
Davidoff Year Of The Ox 12/30/2020 92
Davidoff Year Of The Rooster 1/31/2018 79
Debonaire Daybreak Toro 4/30/2018 92
Diamond Crown Maximus Toro #4 7/2/2020 89
Dias De Gloria Double Toro 11/11/2019 86
Diesel Delirium Limited Edition 2020 12/19/2020 86
Diesel Whiskey Row Robusto 10/10/2018 88
Diplomatico By Mombacho Cigars 11/30/2020 90
Don Carlos Edicion De Aniversario 2013 4/23/2018 89
Don Carlos Edicion De Aniversario 2015 4/8/2019 92
Don Pepin Garcia 15th Anniversary Limited Edition Toro 5/30/2018 88
Don Pepin Garcia Original TAA Exclusive 2019 7/3/2019 87
Drew Estate Liga Privada No. 9 9/15/2020 91
Drew Estate Liga Privada T52 Belicoso 5/14/2018 91
Drew Estate Nasty Fritas 12/18/2018 91
Drew Estate Undercrown ShadyXX 9/19/2020 91
Drew Estate: Undercrown 10 11/21/2021 91
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Sobremesa Corona Grande 4/10/2019 92
Emilio La Musa Robusto LE 2020 1/11/2021 80
Espinosa Reggae Robusto Grande 11/12/2018 82
Fonseca Classic (Connecticut) 3/18/2019 86
Fonseca Cubano Limitado Robusto 3/11/2019 87
Fonseca Nicaragua Petite Corona 2/21/2018 85
Fonseca Vintage Robusto (2018) 2/11/2019 88
Foundation Cigar Co El Gueguense Maduro Toro Huaco 2/15/2018 92
Foundation The Tabernacle Robusto 4/22/2019 92
Four Kicks Limited Edition 2018 8/23/2018 88
Fratello Bianco I Lonsdale 11/14/2018 89
God Of Fire Aniversario 2016 7/2/2020 60
Gran Habano Blue In Green Gran Robusto 12/22/2018 92
Gran Habano Connecticut #1 6/20/2018 86
Gran Habano Corojo #5 Gran Reserva 2012 Corona Gorda 5/8/2019 87
Gran Habano Corojo #5 Robusto 6/4/2018 83
Gran Habano La Conquista La Nina 6/6/2018 89
Gran Habano Persian King Maduro 10/11/2019 90
Gran Habano STK Zulu Zulu White 6/11/2018 88
Guillermo Leon Robusto 12/22/2018 90
H. Upmann Herman’s Batch 11/9/2020 90
Highclere Castle Robusto 1/24/2018 88
Highclere Castle Victorian  11/27/2019 93
Illusione OneOff Cartuchos 10/3/2018 85
Island Jim By Oscar #2 Torpedo 1/28/2019 84
J. London Queen’s Guard 12/27/2021 88
J.C. Newman The American 12/31/2021 89
JFR Lunatic Torch Dreamland 1/4/2021 86
Joel Sherman 75th Celebration  7/9/2018 93
Joya De Nicaragua Antano Connecticut 11/17/2020 90
Joya De Nicaragua Cinco Décadas Diadema 8/27/2018 93
Joya De Nicaragua Clásico Señorita 8/20/2018 86
Joya De Nicaragua Cuatro Cinco 1/15/2018 89
Joya Silver Robusto 9/3/2018 88
L’Atelier Maduro 54 4/25/2018 86
La Aurora Preferidos Sapphire Connecticut Robusto 12/24/2018 88
La Herencia Cubana CORE 5/22/2019 87
La Instructora Box Pressed  11/24/2017 91
La Instructora Delicado Robusto 12/7/2019 88
La Instructora Force of Nature 5/28/2018 93
La Instructora Perfection Invicto 4/24/2019 84
La Mission De L’Atelier 1989 4/16/2018 91
La Palina Bronze Label 3/13/2020 90
La Unica No. 400 8/4/2020 87
Las Calaveras EL 2020 11/10/2020 90
Liga Privada Bauhaus 8/27/2021 88
Liga Privada T52 Petit Corona 12/10/2018 86
Liga Privada Unico Year Of The Rat (2020) 7/22/2020 90
Macanudo Inspirado Green Toro 12/2/2020 88
Macanudo Inspirado Red Toro 8/1/2018 89
Martinez Patrimonio Torpedo 11/9/2021 86
Mbombay Corojo Oscuro 5/23/2018 86
Micallef Experiencia La Crema Toro 7/8/2020 91
Micallef Herencia Habano Toro 10/31/2020 91
Micallef Leyenda Special Edition 11/24/2021 90
Micallef Migdalia Corona Extra 10/20/2019 92
Micallef Reserva Limitada Privada 8/6/2020 90
Montecristo Epic Craft Cured Belicoso 1/20/2018 88
Montecristo Epic Vintage 12 Toro 11/12/2021 91
Montecristo Espada Oscuro 9/14/2019 91
Montecristo Grupo De Maestros Private Batch IV 10/31/2018 86
Montecristo Nicaragua Series Robusto 1/21/2019 87
Montecristo No. 2 12/2/2017 97
Montecristo Open Master 12/5/2018 90
Moore & Bode Adelante 2/26/2018 93
Moore & Bode American Fire 9/5/2018 92
Moore & Bode American Riot 5/29/2019 85
Moore & Bode Candela 2/10/2018 91
Moore & Bode Flamboyân Full Brass 5/7/2018 82
Moore & Bode Tambaku 9/11/2018 89
Moore And Bode “Surge” 4/17/2019 89
My Father Fonseca Robusto 10/2/2020 93
My Father La Promesa 9/27/2019 91
My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 12/1/2019 87
Nat Sherman Bench 2018 No. 1 3/5/2019 92
Nat Sherman Epoca Limited Edition 2019 2/8/2021 94
Nat Sherman Panamericana Rubstico 11/5/2018 88
Nat Sherman Timeless TAA 2020 12/11/2020 90
Nova Limited Edition Perfecto 7/22/2019 73
Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado 5/2/2018 93
Onyx Bold Nicaragua Toro 12/18/2020 85
Padron Family Reserve 46 Years Maduro 2/16/2020 91
Padron Family Reserve 50 Years Maduro 5/20/2019 94
Padron Family Reserve No. 85 Maduro 4/9/2018 93
Padron No. 90 Maduro 7/16/2018 90
Partagas Limited Reserve Decadas 2020 2/10/2021 89
Patina Maduro Oxidation 11/24/2020 88
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Maduro 11/12/2020 77
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Sun Grown Super Toro 1/2/2021 90
Perez-Carrillo Encore Valientes 5/6/2019 86
Perla Del Mar Corojo Corona Gorda 8/3/2021 87
Pichardo Clasico Sumatra Toro 12/23/2021 87
Plasencia Alma Del Fuego Panatela 9/13/2019 94
Plasencia Cosecha 146 12/6/2017 89
Powstanie Broadleaf Perfecto 10/17/2018 78
Protocol Official Misconduct 11/25/2019 91
Protocol Sir Robert Peel Natural 12/21/2019 92
Quesada 1974 10/15/2019 90
Quesada 1974 Toro 12/23/2021 85
Quesada Casa Magna Box Pressed Toro 1/4/2019 90
Quesada Casa Magna Liga F Churchill 11/4/2021 93
Quesada Oktoberfest 10 Year Anniversary 12/26/2021 89
Quesada Vega Magna Toro 10/1/2018 94
Ramon Allones By AJ Fernandez 8/6/2018 91
Ramon Allones Superiores 1/30/2019 65
Rock-A-Feller Dominican Blue 11/1/2019 93
Rocky Patel Cigar Smoking World Championship Robusto 11/2/2020 89
Rocky Patel Prohibition Broadleaf 3/7/2019 84
Rocky Patel Quarter Century 12/27/2020 80
Rojas Street Tacos Barbacoa 12/3/2021 88
RoMa Craft Tobac Cromagnon Mandible 7/24/2019 94
RoMa Craft Tobac Intemperance BA XXI Ambition 6/24/2019 92
Romeo San Andrés By Romeo Y Julieta Toro 5/21/2018 85
Romeo Y Julieta Eternal 12/23/2021 88
Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua 11/19/2020 89
Room101 Farce Lonsdale 9/6/2018 92
Room101 The Big Payback Connecticut Hueso 1/16/2019 90
San Lotano Dominicano AJ & Joche 10/28/2019 91
Sans Pareil Purple Belicoso 12/16/2017 91
Southern Draw Rose Of Sharon 9/22/2020 89
Southern Draw Rose Of Sharon “The Thorn” 1/2/2019 89
Tatuaje 15th Anniversary Habano Rosado Belicoso Fino 11/26/2018 89
Tatuaje Mexican Experiment II 9/30/2019 86
Tatuaje Monster Series 2019 “The Chuck” 10/31/2019 87
Tatuaje Regios Reserva Broadleaf 2/5/2018 84
Tatuaje The Bride 10/25/2018 91
The Vince By Blackbird Cigar Co. 11/30/2021 86
Trinidad Espiritu Series No. 2 Toro 12/26/2021 87
Trinidad Santiago 1/13/2019 91
Trinidad Vigía 10/21/2019 91
VegaFina 1998 VF52 8/20/2021 76
Viaje Hamaki Omakase 2019 9/6/2019 87
Viaje TNT 2021 12/26/2021 90
Warped Chinchalle Robusto 11/17/2021 92
Warped La Relatos 12/3/2018 92
Warped Serie Gran Reserva 1988 10/11/2018 92
Cohiba Weller 11/29/2021 89
Wynwood Hills Mayhem Robusto 3/27/2019 89
Yagua Toro By J.C. Newman Cigar Co. 12/3/2020 85
Zino Platinum Master Edition Throwback 2008 10/10/2019 82

Best From the Brands Lists

Looking for cigar recommendations? We’ve put together some articles exploring the best blends from the big brands, including Ashton, Davidoff, Oliva, Padron, Arturo Fuente, and Rocky Patel.